Request a demo
BetterUp
Request a demo

Agile performance management: How to improve an agile team

December 11, 2021 - 12 min read

Agile performance_people on their laptops

Jump to section

Traditional vs agile performance management

3 new types of (agile) teams

Why agile teams need psychological safety to perform

How to implement agile peformance management for your team

Creating a self-service performance management system

Work — and the workplace — has been transforming for quite a while. The rapid switch to remote work got our attention, though. And the growing pains as we all feel our way forward toward a more flexible future workplace has served to make all of us more aware of what work is and might be.

One concept which has been being totally revamped is that of the team. Rather than the traditional top-down teams, knowledge-intensive organizations are reformulating this concept to better fit their fast-paced environment.

The great thing is that there is not one, but several models which are being adapted to fit the needs of the organization. Customization and experimentation are key, especially in a hybrid future.

Graph depicting network of teams from Deloitte.png

Source: Deloitte University Press 

Traditional vs agile performance management

The unique characteristics of these new types of teams mean they don’t necessarily fit into standard HR processes, particularly the annual performance review. Traditional top-down reviews were created for static teams. It worked for teams where managers, peers, and reports generally stay the same — and at the end of the year, performance is assessed. 

The challenge for HR will therefore be to redesign the performance management process so that it can be adapted for each team’s needs and support people enablement. Amid this changing world of work, we’re seeing commonalities in the types of teams being formed.

subscribe-cta

3 new types of (agile) teams

1. Self-steering team 

The main idea of a self-steering team is to increase agility. One of the most important parts of this is keeping decision-making at the team level. Rather than having to wait for approval, these teams have the ability to act fast, which facilitates a more flexible response to changes.

For a self-steering team to function properly, these changes in direction require flexibility in ways of working and setting goals. Sharing feedback on a regular basis can create greater clarity and alignment between team members, ensuring everyone stays on the same page.

2. Cross-functional teams

These teams consist of people with different areas of expertise. This enables each individual to leverage their strengths, supporting the more efficient accomplishment of team goals all while facilitating knowledge-sharing.

For example, Spotify has allowed people to organize into self-steering squads, each with their own long-term mission and ways of working. With everyone bringing a different skill to the team in order to reach a common goal, feedback is key, not only from team leads, but also from peers.

3. Ad-hoc teams

These teams form and disband as needed. For example, they could be formed to work on a specific project or address a certain issue. It might also be that some people float from one team to another, changing team dynamics.

For example, gaming company Valve is famous for allowing their employees complete freedom to form and move between groups based on their interest in a project. This allows for greater flexibility and alignment with areas of interest for professional development.

Put into context of conversations with managers and their direct reports, this becomes even more useful for setting goals as well as identifying learning and development opportunities.

Creating psychological safety in teams 

According to Juan Castillo, scrum master and agile coach, no matter what type of team you have, psychological safety is the most important element you need for it to be successful. The term was originally coined by Harvard Business School Professor Amy Edmondson and later found to be the top quality needed for a successful team during Google’s Project Aristotle.

It can be difficult to build as safety requires trust, which can only come into play when people feel comfortable sharing ideas or raising concerns without being judged. But in the long term, teams and individuals will benefit from working in a psychologically safe workplace.

So how can HR create a performance management process that fits the needs of these new types of teams, all while fostering trust?

How to implement agile peformance management for your team

Rather than trying to fit these types of teams into a traditional performance management process, allow them to customize it to match the agile processes they are embracing. By enabling autonomy, organizations will actually help their teams to work in faster, more efficient ways

A classic feature of agile teams is working in sprints, which are usually no longer than four weeks. At the end of each sprint, teams complete a retrospective in order to determine what worked and what didn’t as a way to continuously improve.

Adapting the performance management process to match this way of working could include a number of activities: 

  • Sprint or project-based performance reviews led by managers. Using a purpose-built platform gives team leads the flexibility and power to set up reviews on an as-needed basis in minutes — eliminating hassle.
  • Request feedback at the end of a sprint. The best people to receive feedback from are those you work with most closely. Allow your employees to take ownership of their development by giving them the ability to request feedback from their team members, either during the official review or on an ad-hoc basis.
  • Real-time feedback. Agile organizations present a unique opportunity for upskilling and growing your talent organically. Make the most out of this by facilitating the exchange of real-time feedback outside of performance reviews. Colleagues can share praises and tips with each other at any time, increasing opportunities to learn.

As teams share and gather feedback on a more regular basis, this also gives you better insights into how teams are performing across the organization. You will also be able to see patterns emerge on how teams impact one another.

Meanwhile, gathering more frequent performance feedback allows managers to make their teams more efficient and get the most out of individual contributors, as is the point with running retrospectives.

To ensure these habits become ingrained across teams, this should start at the top. As Castillo shared, he regularly asks his team for feedback after retrospectives to see how they can be improved. Leading by example helps show the rest of the team it’s OK to ask for, and receive feedback.

In case some team members (or even whole teams) are remote, don't forget to take that into account. When doing performance management with remote employees that are working agile, certain aspects of the process like performance reviews will differ. In such scenarios, you should also evaluate people on the necessary soft skills for remote work that can also be improved with feedback.

Last but not least, a major part of creating a successful and comfortable environment is by taking time to celebrate success as a team. Let people know that their hard work won’t go unnoticed.

Why agile teams need psychological safety to perform

While teams should be given the flexibility to choose the performance management style that works best for them, there are two things HR can do to facilitate this:

Competencies

Create core competencies which will help you align and compare team performance across the organization. Likewise, having a library of skills and competencies will set the standard for new leaders learning how to best guide their teams.

Technology

Find a platform that allows each team to customize and work effectively with their own processes, and enables Managers to drive more continuous feedback and learning opportunities.

Next steps 

Using one platform across your company allows you to collect, analyze, and compare the performance of different teams on core competencies. Use this data to gain insight into the health of your teams. There is no “one-size-fits-all” performance management process. Instead, it’s time to build an agile process that empowers managers to remain flexible to the needs of their agile teams.

Learn how to evaluate what are the most important areas to focus on for the various teams across your organization, and how to build your processes to enable your people with our latest resources and research.

Lead with confidence and authenticity

Develop your leadership and strategic management skills with the help of an expert Coach.

Lead with confidence and authenticity

Develop your leadership and strategic management skills with the help of an expert Coach.

Published December 11, 2021

Elizabeth Perry, ACC

Elizabeth Perry is a Coach Community Manager at BetterUp. She uses strategic engagement strategies to cultivate a learning community across a global network of Coaches through in-person and virtual experiences, technology-enabled platforms, and strategic coaching industry partnerships.

With over 3 years of coaching experience and a certification in transformative leadership and life coaching from Sofia University, Elizabeth leverages transpersonal psychology expertise to help coaches and clients gain awareness of their behavioral and thought patterns, discover their purpose and passions, and elevate their potential. She is a lifelong student of psychology, personal growth, and human potential as well as an ICF-certified ACC transpersonal life and leadership Coach.

Read Next

Leadership & Management
8 min read | August 13, 2021

How Stanford Executive Education embraces vulnerability as a form of resilience

Learn how Stanford Executive Education embraces vulnerability as a form of resilience that fuels agility, belonging, and peak performance. Read More
Research & Insights
4 min read | November 17, 2021

Managers have a strong effect on team performance, for better or worse

Thriving managers improve team performance. But what about managers who are struggling? How team outcomes are impacted when leadership is lacking. Read More
Leadership & Management
7 min read | April 1, 2022

31 examples of problem solving performance review phrases

Is it performance review season for your organization? Try these 31 examples of problem-solving performance review phrases to help your employees. Read More
Leadership & Management
12 min read | September 6, 2022

How a performance review template improves the feedback process

A performance review template can help you streamline and improve the feedback process. Learn what to include in one and how to get the most out of it. Read More
Leadership & Management
20 min read | January 14, 2021

Want an agile transformation? Leaders must first cultivate an agile mindset

Learn how organizations experience agile transformation when their leaders cultivate agile mindsets, purpose-driven work, and a focus for discovery. Read More
Coaching
9 min read | June 13, 2022

UK leaders develop future-minded skills with BetterUp

Learn how BetterUp coaching helped leaders across the UK develop the key mindsets and behaviours for peak performance. Read More
Culture
18 min read | June 25, 2021

Awakening human potential: Developing people and driving performance in the new world of work

Companies and the people who work for them face more pressure in the new world of work. Leaders and managers must embrace new realities to unlock human potential and achieve... Read More
Leadership & Management
13 min read | October 13, 2022

5 tactics for managing managers effectively — and why it matters

Your leaders have an incredible influence over engagement, retention, and performance. Try these 5 tactics to help manage managers effectively. Read More
Leadership & Management
15 min read | July 19, 2022

25 performance review questions (and how to use them)

With these 25 performance review questions, you can unlock the full potential of your workforce. Start asking these questions today. Read More

Similar Articles

Coaching 

6 employee coaching examples to empower agile teams

Leadership & Management 

Why middle management is so exhausting, and what to do about it

Professional Development 

3 ways to solve your performance management problems

Leadership & Management 

Want an agile transformation? Leaders must first cultivate an agile mindset

Productivity 

Agile project management: A straightforward guide

Leadership & Management 

How external feedback can enhance your performance management process

Productivity 

Start, Stop, Continue: How to implement this retrospective model

Leadership & Management 

What is Agile methodology and how does it work?

Coaching 

How to have more impact? Peer coaching can accelerate team performance

Stay connected with BetterUp

Get our newsletter, event invites, plus product insights and research.