Request a demo
BetterUp
Request a demo

How to decide between your current job and a new opportunity

October 19, 2022 - 14 min read

Asian-woman-sitting-by-the-window-using-laptop-how-to-decide-between-current-job-and-new-job

Jump to section

Know what you want

How to compare job offers

Extra tips to consider

Follow your intuition

Gallup reports that about half of American workers are either actively job searching or watching for new opportunities. 

And when one of them leaves, it’s usually not because of a higher salary offer. They do it because they’re already disengaged, and changing jobs promises to be more interesting.

If the Great Resignation taught us anything, it’s that workers aren’t afraid to leave their jobs if they can have a better life elsewhere. In the first half of 2022, more than 4 million people switched jobs every month.

And it’s not likely to stop soon. If you’re employed and have one eye on the job market, you’re not alone. But searching for a new role and accepting an offer are different things. Whether you’re haphazardly searching or desperately job hunting, the stakes change when you have a real opportunity to move on.

How do you know you’re making the right choice? You might fear failure in a more challenging role, burning bridges at your current company, or being labeled as a job-hopper. You may also be worried about how a career change would affect your life outside of work.

Trying to balance all of these considerations may leave you feeling overwhelmed. So here’s how to decide between a current job and a new job.

Know what you want

Your first step in comparing jobs should always be to start with yourself. Self-awareness and clear career goals should guide your decision-making.

Here are some questions to find a clear path forward.

  • What do I really want out of my work life? Do you want a better work-life balance? Creative freedom? Leadership opportunities? Unless you’re clear on what you want, you’ll end up as dissatisfied with your new job as your current one.
  • Have I explored everything available to me right now? Have you done everything you can to improve your current situation? Perhaps an honest conversation with your boss about your goals would be more fruitful than quiet quitting or jumping ship.
  • If there were no consequences, what would I do with my time? Would you do this next job if they didn’t pay you for it? If not, will it help bring you closer to something you would enjoy? No job will be perfect, but ideally, your new role will bring you closer to your passion.

There are many good reasons to leave a job. Most of them are personal. Whether you’re changing careers at 40 or you’ve spent too much time in your current role, take your time to decide on your next career move. 

How to compare job offers

Deciding between a job offer and your current job involves measuring them both against your dream job. In other words, your vision is the yardstick against which you’ll compare both opportunities.

To do this, create a job comparison chart or spreadsheet. Your three main columns will be:

  • Your ideal job
  • Your new job offer
  • Your current job

Then each row will be a category for comparison:

  • Salary
  • Benefits
  • Bonuses
  • Growth potential and professional development opportunities
  • Company perks
  • Company culture
  • Company reputation
  • Skills
  • Work environment

a-mature-man-sits-at-his-dining-table-at-home-looking-through-some-bills-how-to-decide-between-current-job-and-new-job

Feel free to add other categories that matter to you, like commute time or a remote-work option. Then, fill in each box with the necessary information. How do your current role and new job offer stack up against your ideal scenario? Seeing every element side-by-side can help you see your choices more clearly. 

You should also consider ranking each category. On a scale of one to ten, write down how important each one is to you. If your new role looks great but requires a massive pay cut, your score for “salary” will tell you whether it’s a dealbreaker. You may decide a pay cut is worth it for the extra benefits if your financial wellness won’t suffer.

Here’s what you should consider for each category:

1. Salary

On the surface, this metric seems easy enough: does your new job have a lower or higher salary than your current position? But it’s possible to receive a raise and still be underpaid. Use websites like Glassdoor to make sure the company is compensating you fairly for the time and skills required of you, independent of your current salary. 

2. Benefits package

Weighing a prospective job’s benefits is a bit more complex. Here are some other types of benefits you might expect or want to consider:

  • Health insurance: Make sure to read your plan in detail. Evaluate what each plan covers, how much insurance premium they’ll cover, and what provider they use.
  • Paid time off (PTO) and vacation time: How many days off per year do both companies offer? Will you have to work on certain holidays, like Christmas and Thanksgiving? 
  • Retirement: Not all employers offer retirement benefits. Check if they’ll match your 401k contributions and/or defer your pre-tax earnings into a retirement account.
  • Sick leave. Do you have to use your PTO when you’re sick, or can you use designated sick days? Some companies may also offer mental health days — time off for you to relax and recharge without fear of negative consequences.

3. Bonuses

You may be eligible for bonuses if you work in the private sector. Every company issues them differently, so it’s worth comparing to see which you prefer. Some will offer holiday bonuses, while others will issue company stocks that pay dividends. 

4. Professional development opportunities

Even if your current job isn’t perfect, could it be a step toward something better? A rapidly growing company might be worth sticking around to earn a promotion and climb the ladder. Alternatively, a lateral move to a new company might make sense if you’ll have a clear career path up the ladder or a similar trajectory with more support.

Close-up-of-a-group-of-business-people-having-a-meeting-how-to-decide-between-current-job-and-new-job

5. Company perks

In addition to regular benefits, some companies give cell phones or company cars. Others provide free lunches or the option to work from home. These offerings might be enough to sway you in a certain direction.

6. Work culture

As you went through the interview process, the hiring managers probably gave you a sense of the company culture. Is it a highly collaborative environment, or do they work independently?

Do they regularly have informal gatherings, like happy-hour hangouts or mid-day birthday parties? These day-to-day elements can severely affect your well-being in a work environment, so it’s worth considering them seriously.

7. Company reputation

Carefully evaluate the history of the company and its projection. You want to make sure your job isn’t a blight on your resume, so the more information you have, the better. Is the company growing quickly? Are they more innovative than their competition? Do they attract the best talent? These are usually good signs. 

You can also ask other industry insiders what they think of your prospective organization. They’ll hopefully tell you about any red flags.

8. Skills

Consider what transferable skills you will be using every day. This is the bread and butter of your job, so you have to make sure you’ll enjoy it. Don’t proceed with a solitary coding role if you really value teamwork and face-to-face interactions. 

You should also ensure you’re building the new skills you want. If writing social media content is your least favorite part of your current job, you probably won’t enjoy it more elsewhere. Make sure your new position plays to your other strengths — ones you care about developing.

Young-man-working-from-home-how-to-decide-between-current-job-and-new-job

Extra tips to consider

Your job comparison chart is a great way to compare companies and make an informed decision, but here are some extra tips to remember:

  • Consider your life outside of your job. More often than not, life is about finding the right balance in how you spend your time. If you’re a single 20-something with no commitments, you might be fine working long days and weekends. But if you’re older, you might value spending time with your spouse or meeting other obligations.
  • Ask as many questions about your job offer as you need. Make sure you’re comfortable with every facet of the agreement. This will hugely influence your life for the next while, so it’s important to set clear expectations between you and your prospective employer.
  • Ask yourself, “What if,” but don’t linger on it. What if you took the new job? What if you stayed? These questions can be useful visualization tools, but they can paralyze you if you let them. Ponder on them for a minute, then move on. Trust your gut. 

Mixed-race-Young-Adult-Woman-Works-at-Home-how-to-decide-between-current-job-and-new-job

Follow your intuition

Deciding between a current job and a new job isn’t easy. You might feel a lot of pressure to make the right decision, scared that a mistake will lead you down an irreversible path.

When you feel overwhelmed, remember this: nothing is permanent. As long as you gave your due diligence, you can trust you made the best decision with the information you had. If it ends up being a mistake, you can learn from it and try again.

When you’re stuck on a decision, ask someone else to choose for you. If you’re disappointed by their answer, you’re probably leaning in the other direction. And if you’re disappointed either way (because you can’t have both), you have two excellent options before you. 

It’s also worth noting that, in some cases, there’s no wrong choice. Your current job and new offer may be equal in some ways but radically different in others. Trust your intuition and let yourself be the deciding factor. Then, you can simply enjoy the ride.

Invest in your career

Get your promotion. Make your career change. Build the future you dream about. And do it faster with a world-class BetterUp Coach by your side.

Invest in your career

Get your promotion. Make your career change. Build the future you dream about. And do it faster with a world-class BetterUp Coach by your side.

Published October 19, 2022

Elizabeth Perry, ACC

Elizabeth Perry is a Coach Community Manager at BetterUp. She uses strategic engagement strategies to cultivate a learning community across a global network of Coaches through in-person and virtual experiences, technology-enabled platforms, and strategic coaching industry partnerships.

With over 3 years of coaching experience and a certification in transformative leadership and life coaching from Sofia University, Elizabeth leverages transpersonal psychology expertise to help coaches and clients gain awareness of their behavioral and thought patterns, discover their purpose and passions, and elevate their potential. She is a lifelong student of psychology, personal growth, and human potential as well as an ICF-certified ACC transpersonal life and leadership Coach.

Read Next

Consumer
16 min read | November 9, 2022

Can you just quit your job? What to know before jumping ship

Ask yourself, “Can I just quit my job?” Learn what to do before you decide not to give two weeks’ notice — and how to keep your career intact. Read More
Consumer
16 min read | April 14, 2023

9 of the best jobs with a business degree

Whether you need a career shift or are deciding on a major to enter the business world, here are some of the best jobs with a business degree. Read More
Consumer
16 min read | June 22, 2023

19 most in-demand jobs to consider in 2023

Interested in the most in-demand jobs in 2023? Check out what jobs are in demand now, and how your soft skills will help you thrive in them. Read More
Consumer
12 min read | January 9, 2023

Choosing between two jobs to find a satisfying career

While it's exciting receiving several job offers, choosing between two jobs can be daunting. We outline how to handle multiple job offers at once. Read More
Consumer
19 min read | July 18, 2023

English degree jobs: 12 of the best career paths

You have a bright future with one of the best English degree jobs. Discover 12 diverse and exciting careers that use your skills. Read More
Consumer
15 min read | May 1, 2024

10 High-paying entry-level jobs with no experience

Learn about 10 high-paying entry-level jobs that require either no degree or no experience, and boost your financial wellness at the start of your career. Read More
Consumer
14 min read | September 13, 2022

Should I stay, or should I go? An overview of job-hopping syndrome

Is job-hopping syndrome hurting your career? Is it a good or bad move for you? Here’s what you need to know. Read More
Consumer
15 min read | October 18, 2022

Worried about your job In a recession? How to protect yourself

Will you lose your job in a recession? No one is completely immune, but you can prepare for a worst-case scenario and learn how to adapt with these tips. Read More
Consumer
14 min read | June 30, 2021

Changing jobs? 23 things to consider when making moves

Thinking about changing jobs? How do you know if it's a good career move? Read this article for the do's -- and don'ts -- of securing a new role. Read More

Similar Articles

Well-being 

Learn how to make better decisions with 3 powerful habits

Job Search 

Why are you leaving your current job? 6 answers for job interviews

Job Search 

Looking for a new job? Here are 6 things to consider

Job Search 

Choosing between two jobs to find a satisfying career

Well-being 

30 unique employee benefits that go beyond PTO

Professional Development 

How to negotiate a job offer (5 actionable tips)

Job Search 

Can you just quit your job? What to know before jumping ship

Well-being 

Discover 5 decision models and when to use them

Job Search 

How to politely decline a job offer (with examples)

Stay connected with BetterUp

Get our newsletter, event invites, plus product insights and research.