Request a demo
BetterUp
Request a demo

How to make decisions like a multi-billion dollar corporation

September 2, 2019 - 12 min read
 
 

How to Make Decisions Like a Multi-Billion Dollar Corporation

Jump to section

Separating decisions and outcomes

A framework for decision-making, grounded in science

How to uplevel your next decision

Our teams make decisions all day long — sometimes as individuals, sometimes as small groups, sometimes as a unit. These decisions range from the truly mundane — what to order for lunch — to the momentous — whether to eliminate an entire division. One of the problems is that we use the same process for our decisions, regardless of gravity: some combination of discussion, followed by verbal consensus, with one or two people then assigned to execute. Major decisions are a source of stress, and sometimes create internal conflict, so it’s not surprising that we try to rush through them in order to minimize the unpleasantries of the process.

Major decisions are a source of stress, and sometimes create internal conflictClick To Tweet

For their most expensive decisions, executives at best-in-class corporations enlist outside help to provide guardrails around the deliberation. While this help may come in the form of costly external contractors, there’s no fundamental difference between the principles of good decision making that such corporations seek to apply.

The effort to arrive at a high-quality decision involves the same general steps and components regardless of whether it’s a personal or a professional decision

At root, the effort to arrive at a high-quality decision involves the same general steps and components regardless of whether it’s a personal or a professional decision, and regardless of the size of the team involved. I’d like to share an overview of one popular executive framework for decision-making, and explore how it can be applied to your teams, whatever your budget.

Separating decisions and outcomes

To demonstrate this, let’s start with two questions:

#1 What was the most important decision your team made last quarter?  

This could have been a strategic decision, a budgetary decision, or a personnel decision. Try to recall the details: the options you considered, the voices at the table, and the process of reaching that decision.

#2 Was it a good decision?

We tend to evaluate our decisions in terms of the outcomes.Click To Tweet

Most people don’t know how to answer that question. We tend to evaluate our decisions in terms of the outcomes. Did we end up in the place we wanted to end up? It’s hard to argue with outcomes. The problem is that aspects of any outcome lie beyond our control. Your team might have made an excellent decision, with a terrible outcome. Or, it might have been a poor decision, with a great outcome.

So let’s ask that again: Was it a good decision?

Decision scientists from diverse backgrounds and disciplines including economics, psychology, cognitive science, and statistics, want to help you answer that question. In practice, some of their best thinking and efforts go to help multi-billion-dollar organizations who can afford their expertise. For these companies, a decision about an investment of a few hundred million dollars must be as sound as humanly possible. It can’t reflect the biases of the decision-makers. It can’t veer from each company’s core mission and values. They invest in analysts to help collect relevant information, and to model scenarios. But they also invest in consultants who can help them shore up the quality of the decision itself.

A framework for decision-making, grounded in science

The field of decision quality (DQ) is about 50 years old and seeks to practically apply the findings of decision science to guide us through complex choices. Decision quality consultants and analysts can shepherd major corporate decisions. DQ has been broken down over the years into six basic steps:

Our brains operate according to various programs — “cognitive biases” — that may or may not have anything to do with getting us to a good outcome. 

  1. Framing

    What is the decision being made? This is not always as straightforward as it seems. If your team’s key decision last quarter was a personnel one — say, hiring one person and not another – what was at stake in that decision? Each hire brings unique skills and qualities. In choosing one person over another, you may have been solving for a more fundamental gap in terms of the team’s abilities. Did you consider other ways of filling that gap? Perhaps the most important question to answer was how to shore up a specific skill set, and hiring may or may not have been the ideal way to do so.

  2. Alternatives

    Fully elaborating alternatives can help you refine the framing. Alternatives don’t need to seem equally viable when proposed. Exploring alternatives is a safe way to rule options in and out, without foreclosing on exciting possibilities prematurely. Encourage your team to think as creatively as possible at this stage.

  3. Information

    As you flesh out alternatives and begin to weigh them, you’ll naturally start to figure out what pieces of information are missing. Itemize these gaps, then divide and conquer to fill them. Sometimes the missing piece is information about uncertainty. Perhaps in making that hire, you were unsure if one candidate could rise to meet greater levels of responsibility. What information could you use to narrow the uncertainty, or to better estimate the chances of success? Perhaps some of this information needs to come from other stakeholders, but may entail tricky conversations. How can you plan for these discussions to yield the information you need, without any undesired consequences?

  4. Values

    Any human decision involves values. Intentionally bringing one’s own values into the conversation can swiftly unblock conversations about tradeoffs and desired outcomes. Major team and personal decisions can be an opportunity to refine those values as they are tested in real time. For personal decisions, understanding which values you wish to prioritize can produce greater calm and clarity around potentially stressful and emotional issues.

  5. Reasoning

    Some of the most groundbreaking work in decision science in the last 50 years has been in this category. It turns out that our brains operate according to various programs — “cognitive biases” — that may or may not have anything to do with getting us to a good outcome. You can think of these as winds which can easily help carry you both toward and away from your desired destination. You can’t effectively sail a ship without understanding which winds are blowing, and how strongly. Likewise, any decision made by a human or group of humans should be attuned to, and vigilant about, the biases that can interfere at both the individual and group levels with rational thinking.

  6. Commitment

    Decisions are meaningless without a commitment to act. Teams need to collectively own their major decisions once they are made, and rally to execute, regardless of the choice that each individual might have preferred. Aligning around this commitment at the beginning of the process can be a helpful way to ensure collaboration at its end.

How to uplevel your next decision

Coaches challenge you to find information you might have felt unready to pursue, and to hone in on the core values you want to drive the decision.

The decision making process is meant to sound clear, but it’s not easy. In fact, it’s incredibly difficult to apply the patient reasoning required to arrive at a high-quality decision, particularly if you lack the resources of a multi-billion-dollar corporation. Reading more about this topic is a great way to start. For example, you can explore the free online content offered by the Society of Decision Professionals or by Stanford’s Strategic Decisions Group.

One intermediate option to help you make better decisions is to work with a coach. Certified executive coaches with training in decision quality can help teams and individuals through each of the six steps in a disciplined way. They can ensure that you’re answering the highest value question on the table (framing), and push you to explore alternatives not cognitively available to you without an outside perspective. Coaches challenge you to find information you might have felt unready to pursue, and to hone in on the core values you want to drive the decision. Coaches also help hold you accountable for committing to the decision. In the area of reasoning, a coach with DQ training will have many dozens of cognitive biases in mind (there are hundreds!) as they hear your and your team’s thought process. They can bring these mental “winds” to your attention, so that you may correct for them in your reasoning.

Here’s an example: imagine a product marketing team developing a strategy for increasing sales on an unsuccessful product. The team’s leader has recently had lunch with a buyer who shared that she was uninterested in the product because it sounded too much like something she’d already purchased. The leader shares this with the team, who then seeks to address this market redundancy with their campaign. A seasoned coach would be able to point out the role of recency bias — overvaluing recently acquired information — in this strategy. The team’s campaign is not optimizing for a market, it’s optimizing for one buyer, and, even more specifically, for the opinion that buyer had expressed on one occasion. The coach can further open up the information gap for that team leader around the barriers to purchase for the broader customer base.

Reflecting back on that quarterly decision, ask yourself: Was it high quality? Were there any information gaps, or parts of the DQ process you missed? How could the decision have been better?

And, most importantly: How will you make your next major team decision a good one?

Original art by Theo Payne.

 

 

Lead with confidence and authenticity

Develop your leadership and strategic management skills with the help of an expert Coach.

Lead with confidence and authenticity

Develop your leadership and strategic management skills with the help of an expert Coach.

Published September 2, 2019

Dr. Gabriella Rosen Kellerman

Gabriella began her career in psychiatry and fMRI research and has worked on global mental health policy and interventions for the World Health Organization. She is the founding CEO of the healthcare technology company LifeLink, former Director of Health and Quality Products at Castlight Health, and a serial executive at, and advisor to, healthcare, coaching, and behavior change technology companies. As a thought leader, Gabriella is published widely for both popular and technical audiences in The Atlantic, Scientific American Mind, JAMA, and the Harvard Business Review. She has been profiled in Inc Magazine, and her work has been featured on CNBC, Entrepreneur, and Forbes.

Gabriella is an MD with honors from Mount Sinai School of Medicine, and a BA summa cum laude from Harvard University. She completed her internship in psychiatry at UCSD and holds a California physician's license. Gabriella was awarded Harvard's Captain Jonathan Fay Prize; Hoopes Prize; Rothschild Prize; and Joseph Garrison Parker Prizes for her research. She received both the Eben-Fiske Harvard-Cambridge Fellowship and Frank Knox Memorial Fellowships for post-graduate studies. At Mount Sinai, Gabriella was honored with a Tylenol scholarship and the Gold Humanism award.

Read Next

Leadership & Management
13 min read | January 27, 2023

Improve your management skills with a better decision-making process

Learn what steps you can take to make an informed decision and how you can feel comfortable with future decisions. Read More
Leadership & Management
13 min read | December 9, 2020

Decisions that will make you a leader

Get the run-down on decisions that will make you a leader, transform your impact on team members, and enable you to overcome obstacles with resilience. Read More
Leadership & Management
13 min read | December 26, 2023

Learn what participative leadership is and how to practice it

Learn what participative leadership is, the different types, and the best practices for implementing this decision-making model at your organization. Read More
Leadership & Management
16 min read | October 4, 2021

The cognitive biases caused by the availability heuristic

Learn about the availability heuristic, how it can mislead you, why it can cloud your judgment, and the best ways to avoid its influence on your decisions. Read More
Professional Development
16 min read | May 22, 2023

10 examples of principles that can guide your approach to work

Here are 10 examples of principles that can clarify your approach to work, streamline your decision-making, and keep you on track to achieve your goals. Read More
Professional Development
3 min read | September 2, 2019

Why We Need to Reframe Potential into Readiness

For years, we’ve been investing in employees who show “potential.” We separate out those who show potential from those who don’t, and then route hundreds of thousands — if... Read More
Well-being
15 min read | July 19, 2023

Essential decision-making skills to guide your tough choices

Identify and hone these key decision-making skills to empower yourself and your team. Also, learn several tips for making better choices. Read More
Professional Development
5 min read | September 2, 2019

Solving the Leadership Development Dilemma

Organizations today face a common challenge: they are struggling to develop leaders of tomorrow. Read More
Leadership & Management
19 min read | June 9, 2022

Democratic leadership style: How to make it work as a team

Learn what the democratic leadership style is. Discover how to implement it in your business to create high-functioning teams involved in decision-making. Read More

Similar Articles

Well-being 

Learn how to make better decisions with 3 powerful habits

Well-being 

What is cognitive dissonance and how do you reduce it?

Well-being 

What is anchoring bias? Examples and tips for better decisions

Leadership & Management 

What are self-managed teams (and how can you create them)?

Professional Development 

Examples of behavioral goals: 7 career objectives

Well-being 

Use a pros and cons list to feel good about your decisions

Professional Development 

Critical thinking is the one skillset you can't afford not to master

Leadership & Management 

Improve your management skills with a better decision-making process

Professional Development 

What are adaptability skills? 8 tips to shine in the face of adversity

Stay connected with BetterUp

Get our newsletter, event invites, plus product insights and research.